There are dozens of options in the market when it comes to roofing materials, ranging from metal, asphalt shingles, wood shakes, clay tile, and so on.
Two of the most common roof types that homeowners often go for include asphalt shingles and metal tiles.
They are vastly different from each other in terms of energy efficiency, insulation, weather resistance, aesthetics, and so on.
You may be wondering which of these is the ‘best’ for you before you reach out to a roofing company in Miami This blog will provide you with all the info you need to make an informed decision.
Metal Roofing 101 | An Emerging Roofing Material
Metal roofs are quite common in the United States, especially in coastal areas like Florida, but their popularity has grown in recent years.
Sources suggest that about 18% of residential roofs are crafted from metal panels as of 2024. In 1998, this number was 3%.
But what is causing metal roof to pose competition against standard asphalt shingles? Well, it’s a combination of factors.
Metal roofs are not just more durable, but also more energy-efficient, long-lasting and aesthetically customizable as compared to their asphalt counterparts.
But that’s just the tip of the surface. Let’s break down the qualities of metal roofing in detail to help you decide whether they’re your best choice or not.
Pros of Metal Roofing
They Last 3 Times Longer Than Asphalt
This is one of the strongest qualities of metal roofs. While metal roofs may cost a bit more upfront, they last from 40 to 70 years which is twice or thrice longer than asphalt.
Because it’s durable as well, you don’t have to schedule maintenance or replacement services as often as you would if you had an asphalt roof.
They Hold Up Well in Harsh Weather
Several states in the U.S experience harsh weather conditions, like Texas which often face tornadoes, or Alaska, which is known for extremely cold winters.
Metal roofs are literally built to survive in such weather. They don’t shrink, crack or corrode over time, which makes them a strong candidate for potential roofing material.
They Help You Save on Energy Costs
Metal roofs have reflective coatings, which naturally repel sunlight. This keeps homes cooler during summer.
Ultimately, this results in lower energy costs. Your air conditioner wouldn’t have to work as hard to cool up your home.
They Are Inherently Fire-Resistant
In states like California where wildfires are common, metal roofs excel as a roofing option. This is because they are naturally non-combustible.
In simple terms, this means they don’t catch fire from sparks, embers, or wildfires. Their fire resistance makes them a protective layer for your home.
They Come in Many Styles & Colors
What if you just like the look of asphalt shingles or tile roofs but also prefer the other benefits that metal roofs provide?
Well, metal roofs provide you with the best of both worlds! They can be customized to mimic asphalt, slate, tile, or any other roofing material.
We provide both residential and commercial roofing services in Miami, using the highest quality materials to ensure your roof looks beautiful and holds up well over multiple decades.
Cons of Metal Roofing
They Have a Costly Installation Process
Metal roofs cost 2-3 times more than asphalt shingles. This alone puts some people off, especially homeowners with a tight budget.
Even though the benefits of metal roofs justify the high price, not everyone may be able to afford them.
They Are Noisy During Rain and Hail
The sound of rain drops or hail hitting on metal panels can be quite noisy compared to asphalt shingles.
However, this is fixable. Proper insulation and underlayment dampen this noise.
They Can Get Dented
Impact from falling branches or heavy debris can create dents in metal roofs, especially softer metals like aluminum or thin steel panels.
These dents don’t affect the functionality of the roof, but they can impact the aesthetic appearance.
They Can Expand or Contract
Extreme temperature changes often cause metal to expand or contract. Over time, this creates a gap in the installation, especially if it was done poorly.
High quality installation prevents this from happening, but it’s still something homeowners should keep in mind, especially if they live in areas with fluctuating temperatures.
The Installation Isn’t DIY-Friendly
The installation process for metal roofs is technical and not quite DIY-friendly, unlike typical asphalt shingles.
Installing metal roofs requires a number of intricate steps, like the panels to be sealed, the fasteners to be secured and the insulation to be added properly.
Improper installation can lead to damage later on, so it’s always wiser to reach out to a professional roofing company for metal roof installation.
Asphalt Shingles 101 | The Most Common Roofing Material
Asphalt shingles have been around 1903. In North America alone, they form a 75% of all residential roofs. Their affordability and easy installation are the main reasons behind their popularity.
They are made from a combination of materials, including a core fiberglass mat, waterproof asphalt and a top layer of mineral granules that add color, texture and UV protection.
Asphalt shingles are suitable for all home designs, whether it’s an old-fashioned structure or a modern build. They can even be installed over existing roofs.
Let’s dig a little deeper and uncover the characteristics of asphalt shingles in detail.
Pros of Asphalt Shingles
They Are Highly Affordable Materials
The low cost compared to other roofing materials is one of the best qualities of asphalt shingles.
On average, you can expect asphalt shingles to cost $3.40-$10 per square foot installed, while metal roofing may cost $10-$27 per square foot of installation.
This makes them a practical choice for homeowners who are on a tight budget.
They Are Quite Easy to Install
Not only are asphalt shingles budget-friendly; they are also simple to install and can often be layered over existing roofs.
Repairs are also easy with asphalt shingles. If a few shingles get damaged, you only have to replace those sections instead of the entire roof.
They Are Available in Many Styles
Asphalt shingles provide a classic, timeless look that complements many homes. They come in many colors, shades, textures and designs that you can choose from.
For example, three-tab shingles provide a uniform look as they are made from a single layer of asphalt. Architectural shingles give a dimensional look as they contain multiple layers.
Luxury shingles are made from the highest quality of shingles that provide a richer look made to resemble high-end roofing materials like slate or wood shake.
They Are Sound-Dampening Materials
Asphalt shingles are sound-insulating as compared to other roofing materials, which helps reduce exterior noise during heavy rainfall or hail.
This makes them a big plus for light sleepers or families with children who may be sensitive to loud noises.
They Have Built-in UV Protection
Asphalt shingles are designed in a way that makes them resistant to UV rays. It’s all thanks to their composition.
The crushed mineral granules pressed into the asphalt create a strong layer of protection against UV exposure. These granules are also colored with a ceramic coating to reflect solar radiation.
UV protection from the granules keeps the asphalt underneath safe and protected.
Cons of Asphalt Shingles
They Don’t Have a Long Lifespan
Asphalt shingles may save you some cash, but you can’t expect them to last for too long. Depending on the climate, they survive 15-30 years at max.
This may not be a problem if you don’t mind getting the roof replaced afterwards. But keep in mind that that asphalt shingles may not be what you’re looking for if you want a low-maintenance option.
They Have a Low Energy Efficiency
Modern asphalt shingles often have reflective granules designed to reflect sunlight, but most traditional ones don’t. They absorb heat rather than reflecting it.
This may increase your cooling costs, especially during the peak of summer. Your air conditioner would have to work extra hard to adequately cool your space.
They Need Frequent Maintenance
Asphalt shingles may curl or split with time, requiring you to repair them regularly. While asphalt shingles are easy and budget-friendly to fix, frequent maintenance can add up over the years.
They May Degrade Over Time
Exposure to extreme sun, wind and rain can cause asphalt shingles to degrade over time. They may lose their granules, weakening their reflective qualities.
In states with high humidity levels, asphalt shingles degrade faster because of mold and algae growth. This can not only discolor the roof but also affect its performance.
They Have Environmental Concerns
Asphalt shingles are bad for the environment. Most of the replaced shingles end up in the landfill and occupy a lot of space. They take hundreds of years to decompose.
Even the manufacturing process comes with environmental concerns. Producing asphalt shingles generates volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are toxic if released in large amounts.
Also Read: Which Roofing Material is Right for your Home
The Verdict | Metal Roofs vs Asphalt Shingles: Which Should You Choose?
So, what’s the verdict? Should you go for metal roofs or asphalt shingles? The ‘best’ option depends on your priorities and budget, but here’s a table to help you with your decision.
| Category | Choose Metal Roof If… | Choose Asphalt Shingles If… |
| Budget | You’re willing to spend a little more to get a roof that lasts way longer. | You’re on a tighter budget and are looking for a cost-effective option. |
| Lifespan and Durability | You want a long-term solution that lasts 40-70 years with ease. | You’re fine with getting your roof replaced after 15-30 years. |
| Maintenance | You want a low-maintenance roof that doesn’t need a lot of attention. | You’re okay with occasional maintenance and minor repairs. |
| Climate Suitability | Suitable for areas with extreme temperatures and storm or fire risks. | Suitable for areas with mild or moderate climate. |
| Energy Efficiency | You want an energy-efficient roof that keeps your energy bills low. | You already live in a cool area and don’t mind paying slightly extra energy costs. |
| Aesthetics | You’re looking for a modern, sleek, and high-end aesthetic. | You want a classic roof that complements a suburban home. |
| Eco-friendliness | You value sustainability and the importance of green materials. | You value cost savings over environmental impact. |
| Noise levels | You don’t mind a little noise during rain, or plan on using insulation to reduce it. | You want a quieter roofing option that dampens the sounds from rain or storms. |
| Resale value | You want to increase your home’s resale value with a high-end roof. | You’re staying short-term and just want a quick, affordable roofing option. |
Looking for a Professional Roofing Company Near You?
A secure roof is the bare minimum for any property’s safety. At Fix Up Roofing & Construction, we provide a variety of roofing solutions to ensure you’re safe within your space.
Whether you prefer the long-lasting benefits of metal roofs or the cost-effectiveness of asphalt shingles, count on us for a professional installation.
Don’t settle for DIY installations or unlicensed contractors when you have a professional by your side. Contact Fix Up Roofing & Construction today to begin your roofing project!


